More information about the Underscore mailing list

[_] Ubuntu kickes the WOW out of Vista

Tim Beadle tim.beadle at gmail.com
Wed Mar 21 15:05:09 GMT 2007

On 21/03/07, Ben Edwards <funkytwig at gmail.com> wrote:
> Some of you have probably herd about the Wabbley Windows eye kandy
> that is possible in Gnome/Linux but this demo really shows what is
> possible.

Yay! It's possible to make a questionably usable user interface!

> <run for cover> Maybe one day Mac will catch us with Linux in this
> respect </run for cover>

There's a reason most users switch off dock magnification: it's only
good for showing off what Aqua can do in the shop. It's horrible for
day-to-day use.

> http://www.ubuntuvideo.com/ubuntu_beryl_vs_windows_vistas_aero (the
> first half is windows vista, which you may wish to skip).

What non-Mac-users seem to think is that OS X is all about the "eye
candy" and that, by adding similar effects to other OSs, they'll
suddenly be as good as OS X in the usability department. Exercises in
missing the point, lesson 1.

Tim